By John Rupert | Strange Maine | October 31, 2026

SUBJECTS: Former Police Chief Robert Moulton, The Maietta Network, Andy Cusack (Beech Ridge), and Local Informant Claims

SOURCE MATERIAL: Archived Reports (Falmouth Today, 2015–2016) & Cumberland County Public Records

1. The Core Allegation: “The Local Whitey Bulger” Claim

The second page of the legacy Falmouth Today report contains one of the most serious accusations made against Moulton’s administration:

“FTM has been told that Moulton is friendly with one of the largest heroin dealers in Southern Maine… One source speculated that Moulton is either on the take or has turned this man as a C.I. [Confidential Informant], like a Whitey Bulger.”

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                  THE INFORMANT / COVER-UP NARRATIVE                     |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  CLAIM: Law enforcement protected active dealers in exchange for info   |
|         or financial kickbacks ("Whitey Bulger model").                 |
|                                                                         |
|  IMPACT: Local overdose deaths ignored while high-profile addiction     |
|          initiatives (Operation Hope) gained media praise.              |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+

• The Exposure Angle: Independent watchdogs argued that while Scarborough Police pushed “Operation Hope” (a nationwide program allowing addicts to turn in drugs for rehab treatment without arrest), Chief Moulton was allegedly shielding major local supply lines and high-profile associates from actual prosecution.

2. The Cascade of Protection & Tragic Outcomes

The legacy reporting directly accuses Moulton’s tenure of selectively dropping charges or turning a blind eye to connected local figures:

Individual	Alleged Misconduct / Incident	Alleged Police Action / Outcome
Megan Maietta	Underage party involvement; targeted by police leadership.	Died at age 31 of a heroin overdose. Watchdogs questioned past police failure to intervene in drug supply networks.
Jason Fowler	Multiple alleged O.U.I. incidents involving local racing families.	Reduced/dismissed charges prior to his death in a 2012 vehicle crash.
Andy Cusack	Owner of Beech Ridge Motor Speedway; involved in high-profile 2014 assault case involving driver Sean Caisse.	Court docs in the assault were sealed/kept private under unusual circumstances.

3. Institutional Accountability: Town Council & Management

The dispatch closes by pointing the finger away from just law enforcement and toward Scarborough’s broader political governance:

• The Town Council & Town Manager: How much did town leadership know about internal complaints, FOAA requests, and selective enforcement allegations prior to Moulton’s eventual retirement?
• Political Continuity: With figures connected to these historical networks running for office (including State Senate seats across Cumberland County), the legacy of Scarborough’s municipal handling of addiction, crime, and public records remains an active public interest topic.

Original 2024 Strange Maine Flyer Exposing Chief Moulton